The Short Version
This is a longstanding myth with no scientific support. Shaving does not cause hair to grow back thicker or darker. Major medical authorities (Mayo Clinic, Cleveland Clinic) and controlled human studies dating back to 1928 confirm that shaving has no effect on hair thickness, color, or growth rate. The "thicker and darker" appearance people notice is an optical illusion: shaving creates blunt-cut tips that feel coarser and look darker compared to naturally tapered, sun-lightened hair ends.